Our special coverage of the ongoing U.S. Senate Impeachment Trial of Donald John Trump continues on today’s BradCast following Tuesday’s marathon session that ended at nearly 2am in the nation’s capital, before beginning again with opening arguments on Wednesday. [Audio link to full show is posted below.]
On Tuesday, Republicans voted repeatedly along party lines to block 11 different amendments proposed by Democrats to allow for various first-hand witnesses to Trump’s alleged High Crimes and Misdemeanors and documents being withheld by the White House that underscore other evidence in the two Articles of Impeachment.
Republican Senators blocked amendments proposed by Democrats to subpoena documents from White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney; Documents from the State Department detailing the President’s call with Ukrainian President Vlodymyr Zelinsky, as Trump withheld military assistance and a White House meeting in hopes of strong-arming Ukraine’s new anti-corruption President to announce (not to carry out, just to announce) investigations into Trump’s potential 2020 political rival Joe Biden; Documents from the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), which the President illegally ordered to withhold nearly $400 million in Congressionally-appropriated military assistance; Documents from the Pentagon where officials were reportedly troubled about potential violations of law in withholding the funds; a subpoena for Mulvaney himself to give testimony in the trial; A subpoena to two OMB staffers who carried out the hold on military assistance to the war-torn country; A subpoena for Trump’s own former National Security Advisor John Bolton, who regarded Trump’s Ukraine scheme as a “drug deal” and who has said he’d be willing to testify if subpoenaed by the Senate because, as he claims, he knows more about all of this than is currently publicly known.
In vote after vote, Republicans voted as a block, with 53 votes, to deny every Amendment offered by Democrats, even against ensuring votes for subpoenas at a later date or to have the Chief Justice authorize subpoenas if the Republican-appointed John Roberts, who presides over the trial, felt any particular witness or document would have probative value by being relevant to the case. “One side is not afraid of a fair trial,” lead House Manager Adam Schiff argued, “one is terrified” that the truth might come out.
Meanwhile, Trump offered false comments to reporters overseas at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, where he echoed his previous lies that he would “love” to have Bolton and Mulvaney and his Sec. of State Mike Pompeo and former Energy Secretary Rick Perry testify at the Senate trial, but he just can’t allow it due to “national security” and “executive privilege” concerns.
Back home, the White House team’s public defense at the first day of the trial was not well received, even by Republicans, including Chris Wallace of Fox “News” (which is now, unlike actual news outlets like CNN and MSNBC, breaking away during trial coverage for commercials and regular programming, while leaving the impeachment proceedings in a little silent box in the corner of the screen), the House Republicans’ own Constitutional law expert Jonathan Turley, and George Conway, the longtime Republican attorney and activist husband of Trump’s Senior White House Counselor Kellyanne Conway.
In a blistering interview with CNN on Wednesday, George Conway charged that Senate Republicans “don’t want to hear the evidence because they know the truth, they know he’s guilty”; that the charges against Trump are “much, much more serious” than those against Bill Clinton during his impeachment (on which Conway worked); that Trump is a “pathological liar” who “needs to be removed now” from office, because he is “thoroughly unfit for office”. Kellyanne’s husband also said that he is “deeply saddened” by what has happened to his Republican Party, but sees this historic event as a “moment of reckoning” for the nation and his party.
We’re joined today by MARTIN LONGMAN (long known as “BooMan” to many old time progressive blog readers) from Washington Monthly and Progress Pond, for commentary as the Democratic House Managers begin their first day of opening arguments (which could also be their closing arguments if Republicans vote again next week to block witness subpoenas following the White House attorneys’ opening argument). We also discuss the rules for McConnell’s “scam trial” and why it is that Republicans seem to “lose every round and still win on the scorecard” — not just in this matter, but going back as far as the Florida 2000 election.
Finally, we close with a few audio clips from Tuesday, when Democratic House Manager Rep. Jerrold Nadler accurately charged that Trump’s lawyers “lie and lie and lie and lie”, and White House Counsel Pat Cipollone said in response — with a straight face — that “President Trump is a man of his word.” The heated late-night exchange resulted in a reprimand for both sides as Tuesday’s marathon 13-hour session drew toward its close.
But we close today with a clip from Rep. Schiff’s opening argument, citing a chillingly apt warning from founder Alexander Hamilton about “a man unprincipled in private life desperate in his fortune, bold in his temper, possessed of considerable talents…despotic in his ordinary demeanour [and] known to have scoffed in private at the principles of liberty [who] is seen to mount the hobby horse of popularity””to join in the cry of danger to liberty — to take every opportunity of embarrassing the General Government & bringing it under suspicion — to flatter and fall in with all the nonsense of the zealots of the day — It may justly be suspected that his object is to throw things into confusion that he may ‘ride the storm and direct the whirlwind.”
Of course lawyers are “supposed” to defend their clients but to stand there and lie and not be held accountable? Roberts should state, “sir, you are lying, if you don’t have a better defense then we should move on.” Just galling that no one can call these folks out on their BS.
Brad writes: “Meanwhile, Trump offered false comments to reporters overseas at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, where he echoed his previous lies that he would ‘love’ to have Bolton and Mulvaney and his Sec. of State Mike Pompeo and former Energy Secretary Rick Perry testify at the Senate trial, but he just can’t allow it due to ‘national security’ and ‘executive privilege’ concerns.”
Sounds like Trump’s excuse for not releasing his tax forms — gee, he’d “love to” but blah-audit-blah. Sadly, it’s just really some other reason — other, that is, than his own effort to block their release. It is amazing how Trump is able find constraints on what he’d “love to” do when what he’d “love to” do would cost him bigly. No such constraints on him seem to exist elsewhere.