On today’s BradCast we mark the Presidents’ Day holiday honoring the birthdays of both George Washington and Abraham Lincoln, with a quip from our friend Marcy Wheeler, independent national security journalist at Emptywheel, who tweeted: “Happy President’s Day, America, a holiday celebrating the guy who said Presidents should not be kings and the guy who said insurrectionists should not be President.” [Audio link to full show follows this summary.]
Among our stories covered in that spirit today…
FIRST: During a stunning, hastily called news conference over the weekend in Pakistan, a top official alleged that the nation’s recent parliamentary election was littered with fraud. He claims to know because, he says, he was in charge of it in one of the country’s largest provinces. The official now claims to be ashamed of what he did, “stabbing the country in its back”, and announced that he was both resigning and turning himself in to law enforcement. “We converted losers into winners, reversing margins of 70,000 votes of independent candidates for 13 national Parliament seats,” he said on Saturday, as fraud allegations stemmed from, among other things, Internet and cell service that was shut down on Election Day, as polling locations were moved at the last minute.
THEN: Contrast that potentially very real election fraud, announced by a real whistleblower who expects to be thrown in prison for his crime, with the endless phony allegations of “election fraud” by Donald Trump and his duped supporters following the 2020 election. Those claims, shamefully, continue all the way up through today. Just last year, when Trump was again asked for evidence of fraud in the 2020 election, he cited an oft-debunked documentary film released in 2022 called 2000 Mules. It was a film made by convicted (and Trump-pardoned) election fraudster Dinesh D’Souza in partnership with the long-ago discredited Rightwing Texas-based “election fraud” group called True the Vote, as headed up by a woman named Catherine Engelbrecht.
Trump told CNN that the group had “found millions of votes on camera, on government cameras, where they were stuffing ballot boxes.” We already knew all of that was a lie. The much-debunked 2000 Mules film actually showed no such thing to anyone actually paying attention to it. But last week, it was reported that True the Vote was forced to admit in a court filing to the state of Georgia — which is suing the group for information on their so-called “whistleblowers”, who they had claimed were insiders to massive Democratic fraud in 2020 — that they actually have no such information. They have no documentation, records of any conversations, or even contact details for the so-called “whistleblowers” and “informants” they said they had built their case on in their phony “documentary”.
FINALLY: On Friday, Russia‘s democratic hero and Kremlin opponent Alexei Navalny died in an Arctic penal colony. He had been a prisoner of Vladimir Putin‘s on trumped-up charges since returning to Russia in 2021 after an assassination attempt (stunning details of which are revealed “live” in the extraordinary 2022 documentary Navalny). His death at 47-years of age stunned supporters, many of whom had assumed he would one day unseat Putin to become “Russia’s first George Washington”, it’s first truly democratic leader. Instead, as one lamented, he will be their “Martin Luther King”, as a moral example that will inspire generations of freedom seeking Russians.
On Monday, Navalny’s widow Yulia Navalnaya again demanded the return of his body, which she charges Russia will keep long enough to hide allow any traces of the nerve agent she believes was used to kill him to dissipate. She also vowed to continue his fight against the Kremlin.
World leaders, including President Biden, upon word of Navalny’s death, condemned Putin. Our own disgraced former President, however — a huge Putin fan — waited for three days before issuing an unhinged rant on his social media in which, after mentioning Navalny’s name, quickly became a lengthy screed about his own legal problems.
In a chilling — if inspiring — portion of the documentary film Navalny, when asked by the filmmaker for a message to supporters if he is killed upon his then-planned return to Russia. He says, in English, “My message is very simple: don’t give up.” The filmmaker then asks him to respond directly to the camera in Russian.
“Listen, I’ve got something very obvious to tell you,” Navalny quips. “You’re not allowed to give up. If they decide to kill me, it means that we are incredibly strong. We need to utilize this power — to not give up, to remember we are a huge power that is being oppressed by these bad dudes. We don’t realize how strong we actually are.”
Navalny then adds a familiar quote: “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good people to do nothing. So don’t be inactive.”
Putin is expected to win his fourth term as Russia’s leader in Presidential “elections” next month. He faces no real opposition given that any such candidates have now been either jailed, killed or forced to live in exile.
Navalny’s mother is in Russia. His wife is abroad, in Brussels today.
“As she’s just accused Putin of murdering her husband, a trip back to Moscow as an activist would be highly risky.”
You are correct about that, Rick! I regret the error. Thanks for the heads up!