New York Subway Terror Threat Confirmed as Hoax

MSNBC Special Report On Wednesday: Are terror alerts used as political tools?

Share article:

Guest blogged by David Edwards

Newsday and CNN are reporting that the highly publicized recent subway terror threats in New York were, in fact, a hoax:

The sources said an informant in Iraq who provided the tip had told investigators there was a terrorist plot involving New York’s subway system. That informant admitted he gave false information, the sources said.


Government sources said the three men arrested in Iraq with suspected links to the possible plot had been interviewed and underwent lie detector tests showing they knew nothing about such a plan.

CNN Video in Windows Media format…
CNN Video in QuickTime format…

The additional security measures in New York came Friday only hours after President Bush gave a speech which promoted increased terror fears. Police even shut down parts of the subway due to a suspicious unattended Pepsi bottle.

Across the country, other terror threats alarmed citizens. On Friday, the Washington Monument was evacuated due to a bomb threat. A Rolling Stones concert in Virginia was also temporarily interrupted due to another bomb threat the same day.

MSNBC’s Countdown plans to investigate the correlation between politics and terror threats on Wednesday night’s show. Last night, Countdown’s host, Keith Olbermann noted:

OLBERMANN: And then there is the intersection, or at least the juxtaposition, between politics and terror. We noted it here last week when, after a speech by the president about the war on terror and after the word that the special prosecutor would not guarantee to Karl Rove that he would not indict him, New York City suddenly announced there was credible, specific intelligence about a terror threat to its subway system.


OLBERMANN: Last Thursday, we spoke of at least 13 coincidences of timing between bad political news for the government and a terror or terror-related event. We will be presenting a special report detailing those and other coincidences on Wednesday night’s edition of this news hour, “The Nexus of Politics and Terror” on COUNTDOWN this Wednesday at 8:00 and midnight Eastern here on MSNBC.

Share article:

Reader Comments on

New York Subway Terror Threat Confirmed as Hoax

27 Comments

(Comments are now closed.)


27 Responses

  1. 1)
    Dredd said on 10/11/2005 @ 6:58am PT: [Permalink]

    One wonders how many pennies were spent trying to determine the veracity of the claims before spending millions of dollars reacting to the sham.

    The neoCon administration likes scares so it does not investigate them.

    It just lets the public experience sham fear and sham terrorist threats.

    This admin is pathetic.

  2. 2)
    Vance said on 10/11/2005 @ 7:26am PT: [Permalink]

    Better late than never for the MSM to address this. During the run-up to the 2004 elections, we saw this over and over and over. How long before we start seeing the Terror Alert Level start bouncing up and down again?

    On a side note: Do you know where your duct tape is?

  3. 3)
    jIMcIRILE said on 10/11/2005 @ 7:27am PT: [Permalink]

    Go, Olbermann–the only journalist to speak the truth about the 2004 elections until the networks shut him down.

    Just imagine if he actually starts to question the Big Kahuna–9-11. Oh, my God…

  4. 5)
    ThomNYC said on 10/11/2005 @ 10:21am PT: [Permalink]

    This sickens so many New Yorkers. According to polls (yes, we all know polls can be manipulated), more than 89% of New York City residents felt the Mayor’s announcement about the threat was appropriate.

    Remember, this mayor is expected to easily win re-election. He is a moderate Republican. New York City is very much a Liberal town. Most people I know will be voting for him.

    There is a small, powerless fringe element which attacks him for being white, or Jewish, or wealthy, or short… None of those things makes him a bad mayor.

    So, he doesn’t need to divert attention with fake news like some people we know. I actually think if he weren’t popular he would just step down.

    He got information which seemed very real and very scary. He got analysis of the information from some of the best intelligence people in the world. The FBI stood next to him and the NYPD in complete support of what was being announced.

    He doesn’t need to apologize to us for being on the job and protecting the citizens he serves.

    I am sure some in Washington are pleased that Bloomberg got played… or did he? Or did he get played by some group in America which plants information in order to divert attention from its own sins???

    We probably won’t find out a lot of things which happen during the GW Bush years. It’s all either classified or part of an ongoing investigation… everything!!! What does that say about them?

    And yet, they say it’s Patriotic to monitor my library card usage… they say there is no right to privacy in the Constitution… they brought back a lot of stuff from the McCarthy Era.

    But, America can’t ask them a question about anything… "Classified… ongoing investigation" or they just change the subject and ignore the question forever.

  5. 7)
    MarkH said on 10/11/2005 @ 1:55pm PT: [Permalink]

    Just how does Bloomberg, a Republican, get elected in Liberal City, er New York City? What are the politics there that result in several Republican mayors? Just curious.

    Re: Privacy

    You vote for a Republican you get no privacy.
    You vote for a Democrat you get privacy.

    Your choice.

    Re: Voting Rights

    The citizens of Washington, D.C. have no representation in Congress. The 2000 and 2004 presidential elections appear clearly to have been stolen.

    You vote for a Republican you get no voting rights.
    You vote for a Democrat you get voting rights.

    And they say there’s no differrence between a Dem and a Repub…

    We should have two Constitutional Amendments proposed (I don’t expect Repubs would let them pass, but it would make the differences clearer to the public): one to guarantee Privacy, just as Free Speech is guaranteed; one to guarantee Voting Rights for every American.

  6. 9)
    Pissed Off American said on 10/11/2005 @ 6:31pm PT: [Permalink]

    "BOO" is the only word in the English language that Bush can spell correctly in two out of three attempts. However, the lack of a "ZE" ending seems to trip him up occasionally.

  7. 10)
    m3 said on 10/12/2005 @ 11:44pm PT: [Permalink]

    I’m suprised there isn’t more of this…

    If we’re torturing people… and they actually know nothing… their only choice is to make shit up or become resigned to receiving more torture.

    I wonder if this was an intentional hoax… or just "intelligence" obtained through torture?

  8. 11)
    bluebear2 said on 10/12/2005 @ 5:26am PT: [Permalink]

    m3 said "I wonder if this was an intentional hoax…"

    Hmm – let me see – Miller to testify, Rove called to testify with possibility of indictment, DeLay indicted 3 times, Libby implicated, 39% Bush approval rate, etc. etc. etc.

    Gosh what do you think?

  9. 14)
    bluebear2 said on 10/12/2005 @ 7:14am PT: [Permalink]

    Regarding U2 #12 – Can anyone enlighten me regarding Tom Flocco?

    His reports appear to be way out on the fringe, yet seem to bear a hint of the truth.

  10. 15)
    czaragorn said on 10/12/2005 @ 7:56am PT: [Permalink]

    BB2 – Good query re: Tom Flocco. I think he has the goods on the assassination of my old friend John Jr, although some of his allegations must be off and there must be omissions, for example. I treat his stuff with caution, but I refuse to simply dismiss it out of hand. These reptiles will apparently stop at nothing, so that would by definition include all of the above…

    Bob

  11. 16)
    ThomNYC said on 10/12/2005 @ 8:25am PT: [Permalink]

    MarkH #7,

    Bloomberg is Moderate. Basically, Bloomberg is fiscally conservative and socially liberal.

    It comes down to business sense really.

    There rarely emerges a Democrat who manage an operation as big as this amazing city.

    Guiliani wasn’t such a great guy… then came 9/11… Different world since then.

    The Bush folks are very aware of votes… always have been. They hold NYC’s lack of votes for Bush against us. Hence, he had never been here before he started exploiting victims of 9/11 for his own gains.

    And, New Orleans better not hold out too long for all those great things Bush promised. It never comes.

  12. 17)
    bluebear2 said on 10/12/2005 @ 8:27am PT: [Permalink]

    czaragorn

    Reading Tom makes my head spin! Hard to believe it all, but then again hard not to believe it either.

    Did you make it back to my Kurt Vonnegut Post?

    The thread has moved way down the page. Brad and all have been very prolific recently. Or it could just be that so much is happening on so many levels.

  13. 18)
    U2 said on 10/12/2005 @ 8:40am PT: [Permalink]

    It does have a ring of truth to it, in that US and Israeli intelligence are behind all the terrorist attacks that they blame al-CIAduh for….9-11, Bali, Madrid, London, the Hariri assasinatiion…..

    I couldn’t find out anything about Tom Heneghan, or why he can claim the status of "national security and U.S. intelligence expert". The only thing I did find was a link from the source article at stewweb.com, to Hal Turner’s webpage, where Stew and Tom have a live webcast every Thursday as Hal’s guests. Hal Turner’s website is a white aryan supremacist nazi thing, so it’s hard to take this information seriously, especially when it hasn’t been reported anywhere else……but still……I think the Busheviks had another big "terrorist" attack planned, and someone put a stop to it. The motivation for the warnings was real. I’m just sorry the information came from people like this.

  14. 19)
    czaragorn said on 10/12/2005 @ 9:16am PT: [Permalink]

    BB2 – Indeed I did catch your post as it went by. I’d already seen it somewhere, as I’m a HUGE fan of Kurt’s. (In fact I was once one of 300 undergrads applying for a 6-person creative writing seminar with him. He was very kind, explaining that early in the career of every great artist come instances of rejection, and that, sadly, for most of us this would be just one more. Then he invited us up to his desk to submit our manuscripts. I just got him to sign mine and took it home for a keepsake.) Thinking about what might have been (and all the base evil that surely would never have been) had the votes just been fairly and accurately counted in 2000 makes me weep with rage! I gotta give those SOBs credit for screwing up HUGE if they really have to screw up, as they apparently do.
    Sorry about the lengthy post, but Brad shouldn’t have any monopoly on prolificity 😉

    Bob

  15. 20)
    czaragorn said on 10/12/2005 @ 9:19am PT: [Permalink]

    And Dredd #1 – How much in all have all the red flags for political putposes that Ridge owned up to cost us, at least those lowly actual taxpayers among us? I’d really like to know what all those fake ruses have cost us to date…

  16. 21)
    merifour said on 10/12/2005 @ 10:26am PT: [Permalink]

    I don’t believe any of the propaganda spewing from the mouth of bushco. We are always being threatened by the terrorists…well go figure. This is the War president, so he has to make sure we are all scared out of our wits. The timing of these events is so obvious. I haven’t even read the article noted, as I dismissed the whole incident as soon it was announced, right after another War on Terror speech.

    When one begins with the premise that 911 was an inside job one begins to view everything since then in a new light. I, for one, believed it was on the day I watched the buildings burn. I was glad to see that many are seriously researching this and there is so much evidence that shows the official story is bogus.

    I have been to the Tom Flocco site. I need to spend some time there as I am not quite sure how to read him yet. The VK Durham stuff has me interested. She takes no prisoners. The rantings of an demented woman or is there some truth there, I don’t know and need to look further into her claims. M4 (who proudly wears her tin foil hat-shaped like a pyramid)

  17. 23)
    Uncle Bob said on 10/14/2005 @ 4:27am PT: [Permalink]

    And now, in other news:

    "Half of your history is a hoax!

    A shocking report on how americans don’t know jack shit about what happend last week and, even more so, if it was real or they confuse it with some TV series…"

  18. 24)
    brad (not that one) said on 10/15/2005 @ 8:24pm PT: [Permalink]

    one website committed to exposing fake "terror"…
    on 9/11, london, other incidents is
    http://team8plus.org
    team8+
    these are real researchers, not conspiracy kooks.

    another good place to start is 911review.org
    911review
    check out the
    911Encyclopedia
    TONS of info compiled about comapies, people etc… not just on 9/11 but all the neo con agenda.

    Bill Mahr and others are finally catching on a bit
    9/11 gave them the excuse they needed to invade Iraq
    it was planned a week after busshie got in office, actually way before that
    cheers
    Brad M

  19. 25)
    merifour said on 10/16/2005 @ 9:22am PT: [Permalink]

    #24 Brad, well there you have it, ‘conspiracy kooks, got my attention….LOL. Just kidding of course, I don’t mind being labeled a kook at all, rather I am honored by the label. I totally agree regarding the ‘real researchers’ , I am pretty sure they were labeled ‘kooks’ too, when they started investigating this stuff. I love it when all the conspiracies turn out to be true. Ra..Ra…Ra…!

    BTW, a poster in rove’s room when he was young, was of sleeping lady liberty, with a slogan, Wake Up America. A special thank you to rove for helping wake us up. M4

(Comments are now closed.)


BB SIDEBAR NOTICE

Thanks to you, The BRAD BLOG has been trouble-making and muckraking for … 22 YEARS!!!

Please help The BRAD BLOG, BradCast and Green News Report remain independent and 100% reader and listener supported in our 23rd YEAR!!!

ONE TIME
any amount...

MONTHLY
any amount...

OR VIA SNAIL MAIL
Make check out to...
Brad Friedman / BRAD BLOG
7095 Hollywood Blvd., #594
Los Angeles, CA 90028

RECENT POSTS

Idle Hands…

Time off, and an update on the BRAD BLOG update...

Sunday ‘Have You Considered Treason?’ Toons

THIS WEEK: The Unstoppable Steal ... The Colbert Canary ... The Paxton Primer ...

Republicans Are Revolting: ‘BradCast’ 5/21/2026

Guests: Heather Digby Parton of Salon, 'Driftglass' of 'Pro Left Podcast' on the primaries, the ballroom, the slush fund, the wars, the media, Stephen Colbert, and much more...

‘Green News Report’ – May 21, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

Primary Results from Six States and Trump’s $1.8 Billion Taxpayer-Funded Grift Machine: ‘BradCast’ 5/20/2026

Results and context from AL, GA, ID, KY, OR, PA; Also: Jan. 6 U.S. Capitol cops file suit to shutdown Trump's 'insurrectionist slush fund'...

NAACP Calls for Voting Rights Boycott of College Sports at Southern Schools: ‘BradCast’ 5/19/2026

Also: We endorse Trump's endorsement in TX GOP U.S. Senate runoff!; DOJ adds MORE corruption to Trump's already 'most corrupt' agreement in U.S. history...

‘Green News Report’ – May 19, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

‘The Most Corrupt Thing in ALL of American History’: Trump’s $1.8 Billion DOJ-Facilitated Taxpayer Heist: ‘BradCast’ 5/18/2026

Guest: Robert Weissman of Public Citizen; Also: Election results from LA; Mass voting rights protest in AL; More...

Sunday ‘All Over the Map’ Toons

THIS WEEK: South Rising Again ... T in China ... Strait Outta Hormuz ...

More GOP Vote Rigging Underway. Hey, Maryland Dems! Time to Get Crackin’!: ‘BradCast’ 5/14/2026

Also: GA GOP rigs Atlanta D.A. elections; MT's new voter suppression law nixed by state court; Much more...

‘Green News Report’ – May 14, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen...

Do Dems Have the Courage Required to Restore and Reform American Democracy? (Do You?): ‘BradCast’ 5/13/2026

Guest: Kate Riga of Talking Points Memo; Also: SC Senate leader blocks U.S. House gerrymandering; Primary results from WV, NE...

Offshore Oil Rig Fire in SoCal a Preview of Trump’s NEXT Huge Failure: ‘BradCast’ 5/12/2026

Guest: Brady Bradshaw of Center for Biological Diversity; Also: Inflation spiked to 3-year high in April; Dems still favored to win House, despite GOP map rigging...

‘Green News Report’ – May 12, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen...

Virginia Supremes Void Special Election on Redistricting Referendum in Huge Gift to Vote Rigging GOP: ‘BradCast’ 5/11/2026

Voting rights disappearing, Jim Crow returning before our eyes in GOP-controlled state after state; Callers ring in...

About Brad Friedman...

Brad is an independent investigative journalist, blogger and broadcaster. Full Bio & Testimonials… Media Appearance Archive… Articles & Editorials Elsewhere… Contact…

He has contributed chapters to these books…
…And is featured in these documentary films…

BRAD BLOG ON THE AIR!

THE BRADCAST on KPFK/Pacifica Radio Network (90.7FM Los Angeles, 98.7FM Santa Barbara, 93.7FM N. San Diego and nationally syndicated, Monday-Thursday, on many other affiliate stations! ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
GREEN NEWS REPORT, nationally syndicated, with new episodes on Tuesday and Thursday. ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
Media Appearance Archives…

AD CONTENT

ADDITIONAL STUFF

Brad Friedman/
The BRAD BLOG Named...

Buzz Flash's 'Wings of Justice' Honoree
Project Censored 2010 Award Recipient
The 2008 Weblog Awards