Reminder: The GOP Was FOR Individual Health Care Mandate Before They Were Against It

Share article:

I don’t necessarily care for the Affordable Care Act (ACA or “ObamaCare”), any more than any other non-disinformed, non-wingnut. Neither am I enough of a Constitutional expert to argue for or against its Constitutionality, which is currently being argued in front of the U.S. Supreme Court.

But over the last several days, on Twitter, I’ve been asking to hear from folks who have been negatively affected by “ObamaCare” personally, in any way whatsoever. Given the fits and tortured distortions and twisted outrages that Republicans have been pretending to throw over the law, and its individual mandate requiring those who do not already have health insurance to buy some, I’m sure there must be many personal horror stories to relate, right?

I’ve got a lot of wingnuts and Breitbots who follow me on the Twitters, and they are usually all too happy to take whatever shots they can at me or Obama or anything else they can imagineer, even if they have to make shit up to do it. But, in this case, not a one of ’em was able to point to a single instance of being negatively affected personally by “ObamaCare” in any way. Go figure.

There is, of course, a reason for that…

The Affordable Care Act doesn’t actually affect anyone negatively, other than those politicians who may have to run some day against the party that went to the mat to pass a bill that actually will help a lot of Americans — even if it was a bill that Republicans themselves had initially proposed, but failed to pass when they had the chance.

While a far better system of health care could have been — arguably should have been — at least fought for by the Democrats, what I hate even more than “ObamaCare” are the out and out lies about it from political opponents who are willing to put lives at risk in order to try and score political points by attacking it.

No, it is not “a government takeover of the health care system,” no matter how many times folks like Rick Santorum, Rush Limbaugh and all the other Republican Party hacks, flacks and liars disingenuously repeat the lie over and over again.

So, as Republicans have taken their phony, 100% pretend “outrage” about “ObamaCare” all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court this week, it’s important to once again remind you that the “individual mandate” in the ACA, was a Republican plan to begin with. Where Democrats, long ago, might have preferred something closer to a single payer system (as still-advocated by morally-correct progressives), it was Republicans who initially touted the need for “individual mandates” as a conservative, non-governmental, market-based solution to the problem of sky-rocketing health care costs.

Yes, Republicans were for the “individual mandate” before they were against it. Specifically, many of the very same Republicans who now pretend to be the most offended by the alleged “unconstitutionality” of “ObamaCare” were also among the loudest voices in favor of the individual government mandate to purchase private health insurance in the past as a matter of personal responsibility.

Some of those Republican individual mandate proponents who loved it then — but hypocritically hate it, now that Democrats support it — include folks like Tea Party King Sen. Jim DeMint of South Carolina, Outrage Meister and Pretend Presidential Candidate Newt Gingrich and Sen. Chuck “Government Will Pull the Plug on Grandma” Grassley of Iowa.

ThinkProgress health care reform analyst Igor Volsky compiled just a few video clips from some of the “51-member coalition representing Republicans who supported a federal health care mandate before President Barack Obama endorsed it.” He describes them in a satirical “PRESS ADVISORY” today as “Republicans for Mandating Coverage”. Here’s his realclips of Republicans advocating, back in the day, for the same individual mandate they now oppose…

But that was then, of course. Phony outrage and pretend concern about “the Constitution” is now. Sadly, their brain-dead followers believe the phony outrage, even if they can’t tell you exactly why. Though both the comments section below, and my Twitter account, are still available to those who would like to share how they have been, or will be, negatively affected personally by “ObamaCare.”

We’ll be waiting — just as we’re still waiting to hear from those who have been negatively affected by marriage equality. This may take a while.

See Volsky’s ThinkProgress piece for the complete 51-member Republican “coalition” of those who — at least used to — support a federal government individual health care mandate, before they didn’t.

CORRECTION: We had originally identified Sen. Chuck Grassley as representing Nebraska, rather than Iowa. That’s been corrected in the above. We apologize to the good people of Nebraska for the error.

Share article:

Reader Comments on

Reminder: The GOP Was FOR Individual Health Care Mandate Before They Were Against It

12 Comments

(Comments are now closed.)


12 Responses

  1. 1)
    Floridiot said on 3/26/2012 @ 3:59pm PT: [Permalink]

    Well, maybe ACA hasn’t killed anyone, but the fearmongering did…

    http://www.addictinginfo.org/20...view-with-son/

    She was an avid watcher of Fox News. Fox News taught the woman of courage a new emotion ““ fear. She feared the President. She feared the Government. She feared healthcare. She feared Muslims. She feared death panels. On February 16, 2012, Hallie Jean Mayes Knauss Culpepper died at 85 years old because Fox News made her fear her doctor.

  2. Avatar photo
    2)
    Ernest A. Canning said on 3/26/2012 @ 5:05pm PT: [Permalink]

    One possible silver lining should the radicals-in-robes strike down the Affordable Care Act.

    We can finally focus on real reform — a single-payer, Medicare for All, system that eliminates the parasitic middle men (health insurance carriers) once and for all.

  3. 3)
    Lora said on 3/26/2012 @ 7:07pm PT: [Permalink]

    Brilliant, Brad…who has been harmed by Obamacare?

    Sadly, I do not think eliminating Obamacare will make it any easier to fight for single payer. I believe the opposite is true.

  4. 4)
    LMK said on 3/27/2012 @ 4:50am PT: [Permalink]

    By the way, there’s a name now for the “phony outrage” often seen on the right. The words is “poutrage” and it goes well with the image of immature political brats stomping their feet and shaking tiny fists when the world ignores their made-up controversies.

  5. 6)
    Barry said on 3/27/2012 @ 6:56am PT: [Permalink]

    The impact ACA has had on me is my current deductable went up. My out of pocket went up. The ACA didn’t allow the huge financial impact of a normal western country’s single payer system. We are all paying more than we would if SP was implemented. ACA directly impacted me in those ways.

  6. 9)
    Lora said on 3/28/2012 @ 4:11pm PT: [Permalink]

    Barry (#6),

    Actually, my deductible and out-of-pocket has gone up too. However, my 25 year-old daughter has, directly because of Obamacare, been able to stay on our health insurance, so for me, there has been a substantially larger net savings.

  7. 10)
    Glidwrith said on 3/29/2012 @ 3:20pm PT: [Permalink]

    To both Barry (#6) and Lora (#9): I seem to recall the insurance companies jacking up insurance rates before the ACA legislation kicked in. Since the HHS only recently decided on an 80-85% cost ratio, is the legislation actually in place? Or did the insurance companies do what they always do and screw everybody before the laws click into place?

  8. 11)
    StGabes said on 4/9/2012 @ 4:57pm PT: [Permalink]

    Yo Numb nuts , obamacare hasn’t hurt anyone yet cuz it doesn’t go into affect until 2014…

  9. Avatar photo
    12)
    Brad Friedman said on 4/9/2012 @ 10:17pm PT: [Permalink]

    StGabes –

    Yeah, funny thing about that. It’s not true. It has already gone into effect (children can no longer be denied insurance due to pre-existing, families can keep their children on their policy until the age of 26, etc.)

    You may, however, be speaking about the Republican idea of an individual mandate. Indeed, that provision of the Affordable Care Act has not yet kicked in.

    So if you’re against the Republican part of the plan because you feel it might hurt you, I am curious, how will it hurt you?

(Comments are now closed.)


BB SIDEBAR NOTICE

Thanks to you, The BRAD BLOG has been trouble-making and muckraking for … 22 YEARS!!!

Please help The BRAD BLOG, BradCast and Green News Report remain independent and 100% reader and listener supported in our 23rd YEAR!!!

ONE TIME
any amount...

MONTHLY
any amount...

OR VIA SNAIL MAIL
Make check out to...
Brad Friedman / BRAD BLOG
7095 Hollywood Blvd., #594
Los Angeles, CA 90028

RECENT POSTS

Do Dems Have the Courage Required to Restore and Reform American Democracy? (Do You?): ‘BradCast’ 5/13/2026

Guest: Kate Riga of Talking Points Memo; Also: SC Senate leader blocks U.S. House gerrymandering; Primary results from WV, NE...

Offshore Oil Rig Fire in SoCal a Preview of Trump’s NEXT Huge Failure: ‘BradCast’ 5/12/2026

Guest: Brady Bradshaw of Center for Biological Diversity; Also: Inflation spiked to 3-year high in April; Dems still favored to win House, despite GOP map rigging...

‘Green News Report’ – May 12, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

Virginia Supremes Void Special Election on Redistricting Referendum in Huge Gift to Vote Rigging GOP: ‘BradCast’ 5/11/2026

Voting rights disappearing, Jim Crow returning before our eyes in GOP-controlled state after state; Callers ring in...

Sunday ‘Redlining Democracy’ Toons

THIS WEEK: The Voting Whites Act ... Iran and Iran We Go ... Happy Mother's Day! ...

Repubs Seek Immunity Law for Big Oil; White South Rising Again After SCOTUS Ruling: ‘BradCast’ 5/7/2026

Guest: Laura Peterson of Union of Concerned Scientists; Also: Trump panel calls for FEMA cuts as MS slammed by another tornado swarm...

‘Green News Report’ – May 7, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

Time to Reform our Illegitimate Supreme Court: ‘BradCast’ 5/6/2026

Guest: Alicia Bannon of NYU's Brennan Center for Justice; Also: Primary and special election results in OH, IN, MI...

The Corrupt Hypocrisy of SCOTUS’ VRA Ruling in the Middle of Primary Election Season: ‘BradCast’ 5/5/2026

Also: 'Project Deadlock' in Strait of Hormuz as Admin pretends ill-fated, unlawful, continuing Iran War is over; The conflict's very real, if ironic, upside...

‘Green News Report’ – May 5, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

Billionaires Spending Millions to Fight Against, Lie to Voters About CA’s Proposed, One-Time Billionaires Tax: ‘BradCast’ 5/4/2026

Guest: Harold Meyerson of 'The American Prospect'; Also: GOP states scramble to write Black districts out of existence; A warning for CA vote-by-mail voters...

Steyer Facing Deceptive Fire in CA Gubernatorial Race for Call to Eliminate ‘Trump Loophole’

Trump-allied GOP opponent lying about progressive billionaire's proposal to end state's corporate 'property transfer loophole'...

Sunday ‘Dead to Rights’ Toons

THIS WEEK: RIP VRA ... '86 47' by the Seashore ... Ballroom Grift ...

‘86 47’ or ‘Weekend at Donnie’s’: ‘BradCast’ 4/30/2026

Guests: Heather Digby Parton of Salon, 'Driftglass' of 'Pro Left Podcast' on the SCOTUS VRA ruling and fallout, the ballroom, Iran, Comey, Kimmel and much more!...

‘Green News Report’ – April 30, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

About Brad Friedman...

Brad is an independent investigative journalist, blogger and broadcaster. Full Bio & Testimonials… Media Appearance Archive… Articles & Editorials Elsewhere… Contact…

He has contributed chapters to these books…
…And is featured in these documentary films…

BRAD BLOG ON THE AIR!

THE BRADCAST on KPFK/Pacifica Radio Network (90.7FM Los Angeles, 98.7FM Santa Barbara, 93.7FM N. San Diego and nationally on many other affiliate stations! ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneInApple Podcasts/iTunesiHeartAmazon Music

GREEN NEWS REPORT, nationally syndicated, with new episodes on Tuesday and Thursday. ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneInApple Podcasts/iTunesiHeartAmazon Music

Media Appearance Archives…

AD
CONTENT

ADDITIONAL STUFF

Brad Friedman/
The BRAD BLOG Named...

Buzz Flash's 'Wings of Justice' Honoree
Project Censored 2010 Award Recipient
The 2008 Weblog Awards