Georgia Paper Reverses Position on Controversial, Unconstitutional Voter ID Law

Share article:

Guest Blogged by John Gideon of VotersUnite.org

Just 4 weeks ago the Athens Banner-Herald in Georgia editorialized in favor of the repressive new Georgia Voter ID law. This law had, just 3 days prior to the editorial, been found by a federal judge to be an example of a “Jim Crow-era Poll Tax” and thus the law was suspended. Critics have charged that the requirement for Photo ID at the polls will disenfranchise millions of mostly Democratic-leaning minorities, elderly, poor and urban-dwellers who don’t own driver’s licenses.

But things have changed since the Banner-Herald’s original Op/Ed. One of the Georgia bill’s sponsors, Rep. Sue Burmeister (R-Augusta), got caught with her sheet down when she made statements to the U.S. Department of Justice who had been tasked with determining the legality of the new law under the Federal Voting Rights Act. Her statements were released along with a story revealing that 4 of the 5 career staff members in the DoJ who were advising on the matter had recommended against giving approval to Georgia’s new law. That advice was then overruled by the Bush-appointed Attorney General and the law was given DoJ approval just prior to be ruled as unconstitutional by two Federal courts.

In her statements, Burmeister is said to have told DoJ officials looking into the law that blacks in her district only vote when they are paid to do so. Those remarks are contained in the 51-page report from the DoJ’s analysis recommending against approval of Georgia’s law. Burmeister reportedly told officials that “when blacks in her precinct are not paid to vote, they do not go to the polls.”

Perhaps it is not so strange then that on November 22, after the release of the statements from Burmeister, the Athens Banner-Herald has admitted that perhaps there are changes that need to be made to Georgia’s voter ID law. Perhaps it is not right, the paper now admits, to force all voters to have a state-issued voter ID card that costs the voter between $20 and $35. Perhaps it is not right to force a voter who cannot afford to pay for the card to sign a “Pauper’s Affidavit” as the original law required.

So today, in a remarkable reversal, the Athens Banner-Herald’s Executive Editor, Jason Winders, editorialized in a scathing article against Burmeister…

You can do better than that, Sue.

Sure, you don’t expect a state representative to say blacks only vote if they are paid to do so. You also don’t expect one to say fewer minority voters means less fraud. You especially don’t expect one to say both.

But as you know, that’s how Rep. Sue Burmeister defended the state’s voter ID law in front of Justice Department officials recently.

That little stunt landed her not only on the front page of this state’s largest newspaper, but on front pages across the country as well.

So what’s an Augusta Republican to do?

Well, she opts to spin damage control with FEMA-like incompetence and shift the blame: “While I do believe that voter fraud is rampant in our state, I in no way believe that African-Americans in my district or around the state only vote when they are paid to do so. If the Atlanta Journal-Constitution’s misrepresentation has offended anyone, I apologize. However, I do not believe that these statements are accurate and they are in no way a reflection of my beliefs on this issue.”

Blaming the media?

Come on now, Sue. That’s so 1992.

Everyone tells me how sharp you are, so I know you can do better. Let’s see, you’ve already blamed blacks for voter fraud. Maybe you could blame Hispanics for your poor choice of words. According to our early look at the state GOP playbook for 2006, undocumented Hispanics are the new black.

It almost seems that the Athens Banner-Herald is playing a little catch-up as they realize that their original stance was not politically or humanely correct. Good for them.

Share article:

--- COMMENTS follow below Ad Content ---

Reader Comments on

Georgia Paper Reverses Position on Controversial, Unconstitutional Voter ID Law

8 Comments

(Comments are now closed.)


8 Responses

  1. 1)
    jdw said on 11/27/2005 @ 1:43pm PT: [Permalink]

    Good. Now maybe the rest of these newspapers accross the country will wake up and smell the damn stench coming from the GOP. How many votes have to be stolen or suppressed before the people demand justice? The newspapers have been in bed with the corrupt GOP for too long. Now maybe these whores will make a clean break from the party of corruption.

  2. 2)
    Catherine a said on 11/27/2005 @ 1:59pm PT: [Permalink]

    And I hope Georgia voters decide to find someone better than Burmeister next time around. Her comments were unbelievably offensive. I am only surprised that voters are not calling for her resignation.

    I wonder if the Athens Banner-Herald got a few angry letters from its readers of color (any color at all!) that encouraged it to back-peddle from its initial stance on the photo ID law. I sure hope so.

    (And I hope folks will write them to thank them for their change of heart.)

  3. 3)
    MarkH said on 11/27/2005 @ 2:11pm PT: [Permalink]

    And the Repubs call their party inclusive. Haw haw haw, what a hoot. The party of white sheets…

    They defended Nixon right down the line and now his WH tapes allow us to hear how he used racial epithets.

    Now we hear a modern-day Repub airing her true feelings (and probably a lot of other Southerners).

    It’s disgusting. Is there any wonder they are Republicans? Even if it weren’t for the craziness of the Bush administration it’s hard for me to understand how anyone who’d moved into the 21st century can stand in the same political party next to people like Ms. Burmeister without feeling sick.

  4. 5)
    des said on 11/27/2005 @ 4:58pm PT: [Permalink]

    Good heavens, do we have to keep an eye on each and every one of them, just to get fairness in our elections and our country?

  5. 6)
    RST said on 11/27/2005 @ 7:39pm PT: [Permalink]

    Blacks only vote when they are paid to do so?

    From what I have seen from across the ocean most of your polticians don’t *seem* particularly black.

    Sorry. It does seem, though, that US politicians are much further down that road than most.

  6. 7)
    Dredd said on 11/28/2005 @ 4:01am PT: [Permalink]

    Imagine what these neoCons say behind closed doors if they call heros cowards (Murtha, Kerry) and issue racial slurs on the record.

    Even tho that behavior took the leadership from Trent Lott.

    The problem is that they are so caloused they do not realize what the public thinks about them.

    The stench is like the rotting bodies in New Orleans as neoCondi and neoCon Brownie shop til they drop.

(Comments are now closed.)


--- Ad Content ---

BB SIDEBAR NOTICE

Thanks to you, The BRAD BLOG has been trouble-making and muckraking for … 22 YEARS!!!

Please help The BRAD BLOG, BradCast and Green News Report remain independent and 100% reader and listener supported in our 23rd YEAR!!!

ONE TIME
any amount...

MONTHLY
any amount...

OR VIA SNAIL MAIL
Make check out to...
Brad Friedman / BRAD BLOG
7095 Hollywood Blvd., #594
Los Angeles, CA 90028

RECENT POSTS

This is What Kleptocracy Looks Like: Trump Robbing U.S. Blind, Republicans Letting Him: ‘BradCast’ 7/30/2026

Cornyn and Tillis' Kabuki Theater on Blanche nomination lets Trump steal millions; Also: Millions missing from Trump Library; Billions missing from Venezuela's oil; 130º heat index near St. Louis was real...

‘Green News Report’ – July 30, 2026

with Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen...

Are Republicans — Elected or Otherwise — Really on the Verge of Turning on Trump?: ‘BradCast’ 7/29/2026

Guests: Heather Digby Parton of Salon, 'Driftglass' of 'Pro Left Podcast' on Blanche's woes, McConnell's life, Beshear's response, Trump's war and Dem odds this November...

Trump’s Hail Mary to Nationalize Vote-By-Mail Eligibility Now on SCOTUS Shadow Docket

Administration's paper-thin appeal to disenfranchise millions of voters rests in the hands of a 'captured' High Court...

Surviving the Pyrocumulonimbus: ‘BradCast’ 7/28/2026

Apocalyptic heat, firestorms in Europe, U.S.; Trump's costly DOGE cuts to wildfire management in MN; McConnell still either dead or alive; Good news for voters in MO and KS!...

‘Green News Report’ – July 28, 2026

with Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen

Thom Hartmann on the Fourth Rise of U.S. Oligarchy and the 2026 Election That Could Begin to End It: ‘BradCast’ 7/27/2026

Author and progressive talk-show host puts the nation's latest, every-80-years Oligarchic takeover into historical perspective, 99 days before this year's critical midterms...

Sunday ‘Squid Games’ Toons

THIS WEEK: The Excursion Continues ... Where There's Smoke ... Freedom Fuel! ...

Trump’s War Expanding, Driving GOP Toward Midterm Disaster: ‘BradCast’ 7/23/2026

Battlefield grows as Iran-backed Houthis attack cargo ships in Red Sea; Oil prices spike again; Markets nosedive; Mortgage rates jump to 12-month high; Trump announces new tariffs; GOP polling sinks; Trump allows Saudis to go nuclear, then tries to backtrack; Also: Our 1,600th 'Green News Report'!...

‘Green News Report’ – July 23, 2026

with Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen...

NY State Bar Must Act on Federal Court’s Disciplinary Referral of Todd Blanche

Deferring matter to Trump DOJ's gutted Office of Professional Responsibility would create impunity rather than accountability...

Corporate Political Spending in 2026 Midterms Shatters All-Time Record: ‘BradCast’ 7/22/2026

Guest: Rick Claypool of Public Citizen; Also: Number of Amazon and gig workers on SNAP and Medicaid skyrockets; Primary elections results from AZ...

‘SAVE America’ Act Won’t Save Trump. Neither Will False Claims of Non-Citizens Voting: ‘BradCast’ 7/21/2026

Six year later, still zero evidence of a stolen 2020 election; Also: Iran War worsens; Climate chaos accelerates; Why we can no longer trust Trump's CDC or FDA...

‘Green News Report’ – July 21, 2026

with Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen...

Sunday ‘CSI: Trump’ Toons

THIS WEEK: Where There's Smoke ... ICE ... Blanche ... Iran ... In Memoriam ...

About Brad Friedman...

Brad is an independent investigative journalist, blogger and broadcaster.
Full Bio & Testimonials…
Media Appearance Archive…
Articles & Editorials Elsewhere…
Contact…

He is featured in these documentary films…
…And has contributed chapters to these books…

BRAD BLOG ON THE AIR!

THE BRADCAST on KPFK/Pacifica Radio Network (90.7FM Los Angeles, 98.7FM Santa Barbara, 93.7FM N. San Diego and nationally syndicated, Monday-Thursday, on many other affiliate stations! ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
GREEN NEWS REPORT, nationally syndicated, with new episodes on Tuesday and Thursday. ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
Media Appearance Archives…

--- Ad Content ---

ADDITIONAL STUFF

Brad Friedman/
The BRAD BLOG Named...

Buzz Flash's 'Wings of Justice' Honoree
Project Censored 2010 Award Recipient
The 2008 Weblog Awards