Today on The BradCast (my last until next week, see “NOTE” below), a full week after the awful murder of Republican activist Charlie Kirk, the political ramifications — and opportunism — is becoming quite clear. And it all has a very familiar echo to those of us, including my guests today, who were around and paying close attention 24 years ago this month. [Audio link to full show follows this summary.]
Back then, an unpopular President in the first eight months of his term saw his political fortunes reversed in the aftermath of the horrific terror attacks on September 11, 2001, as much of the nation “rallied around the flag” in support of that President, in response. His Administration, however, ran way too far with its presumed mandate in subsequent months and years. Innocent Americans themselves came under suspicion and paid a price (sometimes large, sometimes small) for their words and their political beliefs. The nation ended up committing itself to (at least) two, years-long, unwinnable foreign wars. And actions taken against Americans in the name, supposedly, of national security would bend norms, laws and Constitutional rights beyond recognition at times.
Charlie Kirk has yet to be buried. And yet, his most powerful ally, a very unpopular Donald Trump, his Administration and their supporters are already targeting their fellow Americans for retribution — for a crime they had nothing to do with.
After years of describing Democrats as “fascists” and “the enemy within”, Trump now claims that Kirk’s death was the “tragic consequence of demonizing those with whom you disagree…in the most hateful and despicable way possible.” In making his case, he cites “radical left” “scum” and unnamed “leftist organizations” as being responsible, vowing to target, prosecute and defund them for a crime that nobody other than the shooter seems to have carried out.
On Monday, Trump’s Vice President, J.D. Vance, declared “left-wing extremism” was to blame and that “the data is clear” it is “not a both sides problem.” It is “people on the Left” that are to blame for rising political violence. That, after the Trump Dept. of Justice removed a National Institute of Justice report from its website that finds white supremacist and far-right violence “continues to outpace all other types of terrorism and domestic violent extremism” in the United States. The study (now archived here) was there on the day that Kirk was killed. It was disappeared by the Trump Administration thereafter.
Speaking to Vance on the very same show on Monday, Trump’s top White House political czar, Stephen Miller, furiously vowed “to uproot and dismantle these terrorist networks” and to “use every resource we have at the DOJ, Homeland Security and throughout this government to dismantle and destroy these networks.”
Of course, there are no known “networks”, at this time, tied to Kirk’s murder in any way. But that’s okay. Trump’s Attorney General, Pam Bondi, promised on Monday to “absolutely target” anyone who uses “hate speech” that she doesn’t like in the wake of Kirk’s death. When asked about Bondi’s remarks by an ABC News reporter on the White House lawn, Trump accused him of having “a lot of hate in your heart” and threatened: “Maybe I’ll come after ABC.”
(Shortly after we wrapped today’s program, news broke that ABC was “indefinitely” pulling its popular late-night show, Jimmy Kimmel Live!. The announcement came after Trump’s FCC chair threatened to “take action” against ABC and its owner Disney, and suggesting he might pull broadcast licenses from affiliate stations. The threats were apparently in response to Kimmel’s charge on Monday that MAGA was “doing everything they can to score political points from” Kirk’s death. Today, it seems, they scored another point. Though, to be fair, Trump said back in July, after taking credit for the recent cancellation of Stephen Colbert’s top-rated late night show on CBS, “I hear Jimmy Kimmel is next.” So, obviously all of this is just opportunism.)
Oh, and Rep. Clay Higgins, Chair of the Federal Law Enforcement subcommittee of the House Oversight Committee, sent a letter this week to the CEOs of six social media companies, (falsely) instructing them that they are required, by law, to remove comments regarding Kirk’s assassination that Higgins and his compatriots might find offensive. He claimed the “restriction of public statements…is not an oppression of free speech [but] the protection of free speech.” [Emphasis added for Orwell’s sake.]
All of this sounds both familiar and chilling to those of us who lived through the aftermath of 9/11, including my guests today, HEATHER DIGBY PARTON of Salon and Digby’s Hullabaloo and the notorious ‘DRIFTGLASS’ of the Professional Left Podcast.
“This isn’t surprising,” says Digby. “They’ve been telegraphing this since Donald Trump started running back in 2022, that they were going to go after ‘the Left’ and his enemies, ‘the enemies of the state.’ After the Kirk shooting there were MAGA people who were saying out loud, ‘This is our Reichstag Fire,’ looking for that moment they could use as an excuse to do what they were always going to do anyway.”
“They have to start targeting people online who they said were insufficiently reverent toward Charlie Kirk, and getting them fired. So much more free speech. But that’s the first step you take in this,” she adds, citing similar threats from Republicans in the George W. Bush Administration back in 2001.
“I would like to thank the Reichstag Fire comparators for acknowledging they are Nazis,” quips Driftglass, “because that’s what the Reichstag Fire was. Way to go, guys!”
Citing similar blowback against those who disagreed with Bush and his wars after 9/11, Driftglass adds: “This didn’t start with Donald Trump. They have been demonizing the Left as responsible for everything wrong with this country for at least the last 35 years. And the rhetoric has finally caught up with actual action being taken at the highest level of the White House.”
“In Neuromancer by William Gibson,” Driftglass observes, “he coined a phrase called the ‘consensual hallucination.’ That’s what they [MAGA] are all engaged in. They have hallucinated into existence a vast leftwing conspiracy, sneaky liberal media, lots of awfulness that justifies everything they do. This has been set up for 40 years now, that the Left is always worse, always a threat, and always a justification for escalation against the ‘enemy within.'”
There is, of course, much more on all of this on today’s show, as both Digby and Driftglass join us for the full hour, including their insights on Trump’s apparent attempt to start a war with Venezuela; his apparent attempt to start a war with Chicago; his laughable $15 billion defamation lawsuit against the New York Times and much more…
[NOTE: ‘The BradCast’ is off tomorrow due to an unavoidable medical appointment, though we hope to get a Green News Report out beforehand! Otherwise, see ya on Monday!]
Brad,
I got a message from Kimmel urging us to stop telling funny jokes on Sundays (It is Sooo Newsy).