ES&S MELTDOWN: West Virgina Files Formal Complaint with Feds

Share article:

Guest Blogged by John Gideon

Just hours ago Betty Ireland, the Secretary of State of West Virginia filed a formal complaint against ES&S with the federal Elections Assistance Commission. A story in the State Journal quotes Secretary Ireland:

“I am more than upset that or county clerks and their staffs and county commissions had to withstand stress and anxiety over the broken promises and delays ES&S put them through”.

“And, Ireland says, now that the election is over, strategy talks about the problems with Election Systems and Software will begin…but, “We will not and cannot discuss publicly our legal strategy. As before, we continue to work with the Attorney General’s Office to address our options”.”

“The state’s selection committee chose ES&S because of it’s past service in the state and it’s knowledge of West Virginia election deadlines and procedures. Ireland says, “Unfortunately, we now feel ES&S let West Virginia down”.”

There have been failures all over the state. A small sampling of problems gives us:

  • Taylor County’s votes could not be counted last night because the main computer would not read tabulators from individual voting machines.
  • Upshur County’s counter was in such bad shape that as of midnight the county was trying to get a similar machine from a neighboring county
  • Mineral County’s optical scan ballot counter was producing skewed results
  • Ohio County could not count about 800 absentee votes because it was not given the equipment to do so
  • – and ?

  • Clay, Gilmer, Greenbrier, Putnam, McDowell and Webster that all violated provisions of the Help America Vote Act of 2002 when they were not able provide any voting machines for their voters with disabilities.
  • The national media? Mums the word for them, it seems.

    Share article:

    --- COMMENTS follow below Ad Content ---

    Reader Comments on

    ES&S MELTDOWN: West Virgina Files Formal Complaint with Feds

    8 Comments

    (Comments are now closed.)


    8 Responses

    1. 1)
      Dredd said on 5/10/2006 @ 6:06pm PT: [Permalink]

      John, I know when you typed "Taylor County’s votes could be counted" you meant could not, and everyone else will know that too …

      Hey, I hope these election officials do not think there is no sympathy … there is … however … I only extend sympathy to those who admit that these companies are not performing.

      I have no sympathy for the election officials who are not saying anything …

      These machines are mass produced and the folk in W. Virginia are going to go thru what any other county that has the same machines and versions are going to go thru.

      Its a function of mass production and anyone with that same machine is either going to complain about it or cover up the malfunctions.

      I am glad that Betty Ireland chose to speak up instead of covering up the destabilization of the American election system.

    2. 3)
      cor said on 5/11/2006 @ 10:38pm PT: [Permalink]

      ""As before, we continue to work with the Attorney General’s Office to address our options"."

      That should be in bold for effect. It seems like she is crying out for effect here.

    3. 4)
      Dredd said on 5/11/2006 @ 1:45am PT: [Permalink]

      Max 1 #2

      John, Brad, Bev Harris, Jim March, Catherine A, Clint Curtis, now you, and an army of bloggers have been asking this for a long time.

      They have become frustrated at times in their long journey and struggle to try to stimulate the MSM (or national media as you call it) to report this to the people.

      We have a plethora of theories as to why it is that there is virtually a national blackout of this news.

      And it may just be that all those theories are correct, since there are so many media members. And they have different political, religious, and social views.

      And many of them are controlled by their editors and the editors by the owners.

      We have thought that it could be denial, disbelief, pride in our nation "that can do no wrong", or that they simply figure we are a bunch of sore losers or something akin to that. Who knows.

      But I don’t think they realize the danger that a destabilized election system presents. Or how easy it really would be to destabilize that system.

      The vulnerability is obvious when one realizes that most American votes are handled by machines marketed by only three companies (Diebold, Sequoia, and ES & S).

      Thus, anyone with ill will against Americans could sabotage its democracy by controlling only three people in theory. Start with the IT managers at those three companies, or the equivalent.

      And a rogue government could take distasteful actions when all of this power is concentrated in only a small handful of people.

      Add to that the fact that some of the machines are made in foreign communist nations, and one has to resist thinking something is amiss with the MSM for not shouting this loudly to Americans.

    4. 5)
      AKHENATEN said on 5/11/2006 @ 1:57am PT: [Permalink]

      the media cannot be trusted. the govt cannot be trusted. the vote is never honest, and the man at the top is a crook. democracy is a lie, and while the power lies in the proles, still, they will never grab it.

      these are sad truths, but ones that have sustained the test of time for thousands of years.

      big ups to brad and all the work he does. while my view may be fatalistic, i do not think this (realistic) view precludes doing all one can at the moment, for Good. that is still called for, or why bother living?

    5. 7)
      bluebear 2 said on 5/11/2006 @ 2:18pm PT: [Permalink]

      OT (Kind of)

      This could work out really great! New press sec is attacking press. Maybe if he gets them pissed off they will finaly wake up from their deep slumber.

      I love the statement: “Again, the White House is clearly manipulating what I broadcast to fit their agenda. And they are wrong to do that.”

      So expose them I say!

    6. 8)
      MarkH said on 5/12/2006 @ 1:04pm PT: [Permalink]

      I don’t know the WV Sec. of State Betty Ireland, but I don’t trust her any further than I’d trust any other politician. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if she has just realized she’s not going to get re-elected unless she does something big, like crying about ES&S.

      I suppose it’s important to note that the biggest (population) counties of the state were not considered problem areas. Cabell and Kanawha are probably the biggest counties, though Wood county is one of the most Republican areas of the state.

      I don’t read the local papers very often, so I haven’t heard of any problems in Cabell county (my home county).

      One of the dangers is that the real problems will go unnoticed or they’ll only appear when someone (like Karl Rove) puts them into motion during a general election, especially one where a presidency is on the line.

    (Comments are now closed.)


    --- Ad Content ---

    BB SIDEBAR NOTICE

    Thanks to you, The BRAD BLOG has been trouble-making and muckraking for … 22 YEARS!!!

    Please help The BRAD BLOG, BradCast and Green News Report remain independent and 100% reader and listener supported in our 23rd YEAR!!!

    ONE TIME
    any amount...

    MONTHLY
    any amount...

    OR VIA SNAIL MAIL
    Make check out to...
    Brad Friedman / BRAD BLOG
    7095 Hollywood Blvd., #594
    Los Angeles, CA 90028

    RECENT POSTS

    This is What Kleptocracy Looks Like: Trump Robbing U.S. Blind, Republicans Letting Him: ‘BradCast’ 7/30/2026

    Cornyn and Tillis' Kabuki Theater on Blanche nomination lets Trump steal millions; Also: Millions missing from Trump Library; Billions missing from Venezuela's oil; 130º heat index near St. Louis was real...

    ‘Green News Report’ – July 30, 2026

    with Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen...

    Are Republicans — Elected or Otherwise — Really on the Verge of Turning on Trump?: ‘BradCast’ 7/29/2026

    Guests: Heather Digby Parton of Salon, 'Driftglass' of 'Pro Left Podcast' on Blanche's woes, McConnell's life, Beshear's response, Trump's war and Dem odds this November...

    Trump’s Hail Mary to Nationalize Vote-By-Mail Eligibility Now on SCOTUS Shadow Docket

    Administration's paper-thin appeal to disenfranchise millions of voters rests in the hands of a 'captured' High Court...

    Surviving the Pyrocumulonimbus: ‘BradCast’ 7/28/2026

    Apocalyptic heat, firestorms in Europe, U.S.; Trump's costly DOGE cuts to wildfire management in MN; McConnell still either dead or alive; Good news for voters in MO and KS!...

    ‘Green News Report’ – July 28, 2026

    with Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen

    Thom Hartmann on the Fourth Rise of U.S. Oligarchy and the 2026 Election That Could Begin to End It: ‘BradCast’ 7/27/2026

    Author and progressive talk-show host puts the nation's latest, every-80-years Oligarchic takeover into historical perspective, 99 days before this year's critical midterms...

    Sunday ‘Squid Games’ Toons

    THIS WEEK: The Excursion Continues ... Where There's Smoke ... Freedom Fuel! ...

    Trump’s War Expanding, Driving GOP Toward Midterm Disaster: ‘BradCast’ 7/23/2026

    Battlefield grows as Iran-backed Houthis attack cargo ships in Red Sea; Oil prices spike again; Markets nosedive; Mortgage rates jump to 12-month high; Trump announces new tariffs; GOP polling sinks; Trump allows Saudis to go nuclear, then tries to backtrack; Also: Our 1,600th 'Green News Report'!...

    ‘Green News Report’ – July 23, 2026

    with Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen...

    NY State Bar Must Act on Federal Court’s Disciplinary Referral of Todd Blanche

    Deferring matter to Trump DOJ's gutted Office of Professional Responsibility would create impunity rather than accountability...

    Corporate Political Spending in 2026 Midterms Shatters All-Time Record: ‘BradCast’ 7/22/2026

    Guest: Rick Claypool of Public Citizen; Also: Number of Amazon and gig workers on SNAP and Medicaid skyrockets; Primary elections results from AZ...

    ‘SAVE America’ Act Won’t Save Trump. Neither Will False Claims of Non-Citizens Voting: ‘BradCast’ 7/21/2026

    Six year later, still zero evidence of a stolen 2020 election; Also: Iran War worsens; Climate chaos accelerates; Why we can no longer trust Trump's CDC or FDA...

    ‘Green News Report’ – July 21, 2026

    with Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen...

    Sunday ‘CSI: Trump’ Toons

    THIS WEEK: Where There's Smoke ... ICE ... Blanche ... Iran ... In Memoriam ...

    About Brad Friedman...

    Brad is an independent investigative journalist, blogger and broadcaster.
    Full Bio & Testimonials…
    Media Appearance Archive…
    Articles & Editorials Elsewhere…
    Contact…

    He is featured in these documentary films…
    …And has contributed chapters to these books…

    BRAD BLOG ON THE AIR!

    THE BRADCAST on KPFK/Pacifica Radio Network (90.7FM Los Angeles, 98.7FM Santa Barbara, 93.7FM N. San Diego and nationally syndicated, Monday-Thursday, on many other affiliate stations! ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
    GREEN NEWS REPORT, nationally syndicated, with new episodes on Tuesday and Thursday. ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
    Media Appearance Archives…

    --- Ad Content ---

    ADDITIONAL STUFF

    Brad Friedman/
    The BRAD BLOG Named...

    Buzz Flash's 'Wings of Justice' Honoree
    Project Censored 2010 Award Recipient
    The 2008 Weblog Awards