Canard About ‘Rarity’ of Rape Pregnancy: GOP Just Can’t Seem to ‘Shut That Whole Thing Down’

Female CA Republican Assembly leader proves some GOP women as ignorant about female biology as GOP men...

Share article:

Celeste Greig, the head of the California Republican Assembly, recently demonstrated that ignorance about female biology is not limited to Republican men.

But then, that should not come as a surprise. Ignorance, like intelligence, is not gender specific. Whether we deal with global climate change, so-called “intelligent design” or the mistaken belief that rape-related pregnancies are rare, the modern GOP has demonstrated that they are unwilling to let a little thing like science stand in the way of their political agenda.

For the anti-abortion crowd, the notion that rape pregnancies are rare entails what The Atlantic’s Garance Franke-Ruta aptly described as the “canard that will not die.” As she notes, the truth, according to the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, is that “among adult women an estimated 32,101 pregnancies result from rape each year.” Hardly a “rare” occurrence.

The issue, of course, became a central focus of the 2012 U.S. Senate campaign in Missouri when Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO) advanced the idiotic notion that women are rarely impregnated during a “legitimate rape” because “the female body has ways to shut that whole thing down.” The idiocy was resurrected by Greig, who on Friday, March 1, after admonishing Akin for his insensitivity, said “the percentage of pregnancies due to rape is small because it’s an act of violence, because the body is traumatized.”

Unfortunately, Akin wasn’t the first to forward the anti-choice ruse, and Grieg, undoubtedly, will not be the last among those seeking to outlaw the right to abortion, even if it requires lying to the American public about scientific facts…

The canard began with the March 1988 claim made by Pennsylvania State Representative Stephen Freind (R) that pregnancies from rape were “one in millions and millions” — a claim which Freind, himself, admitted was “an exaggeration,” though he claimed that studies revealed that during the trauma of rape, “a woman secrets a certain secretion, which has the tendency to kill sperm.”

There was, of course, no scientific validity to Freind’s claim. To the contrary, the 1996 study by the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology found: “Rape-related pregnancy occurs with significant frequency. It is a cause of many unwanted pregnancies and is closely linked with family and domestic violence.” The study suggested an increased focus on “preventing and identifying unwanted pregnancies that result from sexual victimization.”

Medical experts like Richard Depp, M.D., Chairman of Obstetrics and Gynecology at Thomas Jefferson University and Luigi Mastroianni, Jr., M.D., the Director of the Division of Human Reproduction at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, were quick to dismiss Freind’s rant at the time as “scientifically unfounded” and “nonsense.” Mastroianni, who is a past president of the American Fertility Society, quipped: “Boy, if I could find out what that [secretion] was, I’d use it as a contraceptive.”

When it comes to rape, Dr. Fay Boozman, (R-AR) proved that the ability to ignore science was not limited to lay Republicans. Boozman was a right-wing Christian, a candidate for the U.S. Senate in 1998 and an ophthalmologist. He was appointed by Gov. Mike Huckabee (R-AR) to serve on a medical advisory board for a crisis pregnancy center. Boozman claimed that “fear-induced hormonal changes could block a rape victim’s ability to conceive.”

Although he later acknowledged that the remark was based on his “personal observations” and not on the basis of any scientific study, Boozman, refused to retract it, though he did apologize to “the women and young ladies of Arkansas” for “any hurt” his remark may have caused.

Boozman was handily defeated in the 1998 U.S. Senate race by Democrat Blanche Lincoln (though he would have his revenge over a decade later, in 2010, when he would eventually unseat her during that year’s GOP wave election.)

Not to be outdone by Boozman, John C. Wilke, M.D., a general practitioner and the president of National Right to Life, followed up with a 1999 essay, Rape Pregnancies are Rare, in which he advanced the notion that “assault rape” rarely led to pregnancies. He claimed, without citing a single scientific study, that a rape victim’s fallopian tube contracts secondary to fear and trauma, making fertilization less likely.

Wilke’s claim was described by Michael Greene, M.D., Prof. of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Biology at Harvard Medical School as “just nuts.” David Grimes, M.D., a Clinical Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology at the University of North Carolina, who was formerly associated with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, stated that Wilke’s fallopian tube contraction theory was “nonsense. Everything is working. The tube is very small anyway and sperm are very tiny — they’re excellent swimmers.”

Scientific refutation, of course, did not dissuade Akin’s idiotic “legitimate rape” comment, and it failed to dissuade Greig’s, even as she was initially attempting to condemn it — before she went ahead and asserted it for herself. For fanatic “right-to-lifers,” rape pregnancies are an inconvenient truth.

* * *
Ernest A. Canning has been an active member of the California state bar since 1977. Mr. Canning has received both undergraduate and graduate degrees in political science as well as a juris doctor. He is also a Vietnam vet (4th Infantry, Central Highlands 1968). Follow him on Twitter: @Cann4ing.

Share article:

--- COMMENTS follow below Ad Content ---

Reader Comments on

Canard About ‘Rarity’ of Rape Pregnancy: GOP Just Can’t Seem to ‘Shut That Whole Thing Down’

2 Comments

(Comments are now closed.)


2 Responses

  1. 2)
    Alex said on 3/4/2013 @ 6:40pm PT: [Permalink]

    The delusions and rewriting of history continues with the Conservative mindset.
    If this pregnancy prevention was possible, then why did the Mongols, the Vikings and other marauding and pillaging invaders use rape as part of their conquering of foes?
    Because it gave them a progeny in their new lands so that their genetics would be carried on. Yes it was for fear and power (as well as sexual release), but also for spreading their seed.
    Why do people of eastern Europe and central Asia have more of an oriental appearance than western Europeans? The Mongols didn’t just bring a love of silk to the west.
    There would be far fewer people on this earth if rape did not produce offspring.
    Is this “rape doesn’t make babies” excuse for southerners to deny that they have any relatives who have black ancestry? Then they can rationalize that all their ancestors seduced or had loving relationships with ther slaves.

(Comments are now closed.)


--- Ad Content ---

BB SIDEBAR NOTICE

Thanks to you, The BRAD BLOG has been trouble-making and muckraking for … 22 YEARS!!!

Please help The BRAD BLOG, BradCast and Green News Report remain independent and 100% reader and listener supported in our 23rd YEAR!!!

ONE TIME
any amount...

MONTHLY
any amount...

OR VIA SNAIL MAIL
Make check out to...
Brad Friedman / BRAD BLOG
7095 Hollywood Blvd., #594
Los Angeles, CA 90028

RECENT POSTS

Trump Policies Imperiling Social Security, Depleting Trust Fund; ‘BradCast’ 6/11/2026

Guest: Nancy Altman of Social Security Works; Also: FL Supremes okay GOP's unconstitutional U.S. House map; Ebola outbreak explodes amid U.S. leadership vacuum...

‘Green News Report’ – June 11, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

Maine Dems Elect Platner in Landslide: ‘BradCast’ 6/10/2026

Repub Hilton 'wins' slot in CA Guv general election; Inflation spikes again; New U.S. solar milestones despite Trump; Primary results from ND, NV, SC and ME...

Corporate Donors to White House Ballroom Win $50 Billion in New Government Contracts, Funding: ‘BradCast’ 6/9/2026

Guest: Robert Weissman of Public Citizen; Also: Updates on the races for CA Guv, L.A. Mayor, Trump's evidence-free allegations of election fraud...

‘Green News Report’ – June 9, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

‘Crooked or Stupid’: Trump Rails Against ‘Rigged’ CA Elections, Offers No Evidence, Storms off Interview: ‘BradCast’ 6/8/2026

Counting continues in CA; Critical ME primary tomorrow; Also: Callers ring in, some who have fallen for phony rightwing 'voter fraud' claims...

Sunday ‘Tick Tick Tick Tick’ Toons

THIS WEEK: Breaking News at CBS ... On the Money ... Iran and Iran We Go ...

‘I’m not a Victim. I was a Criminal’: J6er Says ‘No’ to Trump’s ‘Weaponization’ Slush Fund Money: ‘BradCast’ 6/4/2026

Guest: Convicted MAGA rioter Jason Riddle; Also: Pelley charges new CBS execs pushing 'falsehoods', 'bias' into '60 Minutes'...

‘Green News Report’ – June 4, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

Trump’s Favorite Election Fraud Criminal Now Runs Free: ‘BradCast’ 6/2/2026

Also: Not so 'hot' after all, as data finds international tourism to U.S. plummeted in 2025...

‘Green News Report’ – June 2, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

One Failure After Another: ‘BradCast’ 6/1/2026

We are in an historic moment, as the Trump Presidency begins its collapse; Also: Callers ring in on tomorrow's wild California Gubernatorial primary...

Did Trump and His Attorneys Conspire to Defraud the United States?

The court-ordered reopening of Trump's lawsuit against the IRS could have impacts well beyond blocking access to a $1.8 billion slush fund...

UPDATE, Midday 6/1/26: Trump announces plan to drop 'Weaponization Fund'...

Sunday ‘Slush Fun!’ Toons

THIS WEEK: Dirty Money ... Trump Kennedy Center ... Let's Get Physical ... Forever (and Ever) War ...

About Brad Friedman...

Brad is an independent investigative journalist, blogger and broadcaster. Full Bio & Testimonials… Media Appearance Archive… Articles & Editorials Elsewhere… Contact…

He has contributed chapters to these books…
…And is featured in these documentary films…

BRAD BLOG ON THE AIR!

THE BRADCAST on KPFK/Pacifica Radio Network (90.7FM Los Angeles, 98.7FM Santa Barbara, 93.7FM N. San Diego and nationally syndicated, Monday-Thursday, on many other affiliate stations! ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
GREEN NEWS REPORT, nationally syndicated, with new episodes on Tuesday and Thursday. ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneIn | Apple Podcasts/iTunes | iHeart | Amazon Music
Media Appearance Archives…

--- Ad Content ---

ADDITIONAL STUFF

Brad Friedman/
The BRAD BLOG Named...

Buzz Flash's 'Wings of Justice' Honoree
Project Censored 2010 Award Recipient
The 2008 Weblog Awards