Following al-Libi’s ‘Suicide,’ What About the Other ‘Ghost Detainees’ in Libya, Elsewhere?

Where the U.S. MSM continue to fail

PLUS: What of the Bush Regime's justifications for not only negotiating with, but actually <u>working with</u> the 'international terrorist' regime in Libya?...

Share article:

Andy Worthington, who largely broke the story of the reported ‘suicide’ of Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi in a Libyan prison, into the English-language press on Sunday (as we helped that night), picked up last night on our followup to the original story, decrying the paucity of coverage of the disturbing report in the U.S. corporate mainstream media.

Al-Libi was, after all, the ‘ghost detainee’ who had offered a false link between Iraq and al-Qaeda, used loudly by the Bush Administration before the war as a key justification for it, after being tortured by the CIA and Egypt, where he’d been secretly renditioned from U.S. custody at Guantanamo. He would later recant his false ‘confession,’ explaining that it had come about only after 17 hours of ‘mock burial,’ and a session of brutal beatings by his captors which followed it.

Newsweek describes the al-Libi affair today as “one of the biggest intelligence fiascos of the run up to the Iraq War” and “a major embarrassment for the Bush administration.”

Worthington asked why the initial “media silence,” before noting that while U.S. outlets have finally begun to cover the story, one of the better initial reports, from Peter Finn at Washington Post fails to follow up on the paper’s own previous coverage of ‘ghost detainees,’ which included al-Libi, who had disappeared, at some point, from the Bush Administration’s long list of suspected ‘terrorists’ captured following 9/11.

Al-Libi was one of those captives previously reported on by WaPo. His re-emergence in Libya — where he was spotted by Human Rights Watch at the Abu Salim prison in late April, in apparent good health, but refused to be interviewed, reportedly saying only “Where were you when I was being tortured in American prisons?” — was punctuated, just two weeks later, by the surprising news of his reported ‘suicide.’

But where WaPo covered some of the points mentioned in a press release on al-Libi’s death from HRW, they failed to mention any of the other ‘ghost detainees’ mentioned in the very same press release, whose whereabouts had been a mystery up until now. That, even though WaPo had previously reported the ‘missing’ status of those same detainees!

Given the disturbing fate of al-Libi — who, HRW’s Tom Malinowski charges, “was missing because he was such an embarrassment to the Bush administration. He was Exhibit A in the narrative that tortured confessions contributed to the massive intelligence failure that preceded the Iraq war” — it’s disappointing that the paper has so far failed to connect dots that could, in this case, help shine a spotlight on growing concerns about some of those other detainees: A spotlight which may help keep them alive, at this point.

There is certainly good reason to question both the timing, and reported means, of al-Libi’s death, not the least of which is the point made in several media reports, including AP’s, where some have “expressed doubts that al-Libi killed himself, saying al-Libi was a ‘true Muslim and Islam prohibits committing suicides.'”

Yet, as Worthington notes, the Post failed to even mention the current status of the other detainees HRW discovered in the Libyan prison, even as they had similarly been sent there by the CIA following claims of abuse and torture at the hands of the U.S….

Human Rights Watch also revealed that, although its researchers had been unable to talk to al-Libi, they did interview four other Libyan prisoners, sent to Libya by the CIA between 2004 to 2006, who stated that they had been tortured by US forces in detention centers in Afghanistan, and that US forces had also supervised their torture in Pakistan and Thailand.

One of the men, Mohamed Ahmad Mohamed al-Shoroeiya, also known as Hassan Rabi’i, told Human Rights Watch that “in mid-2003, in a place he believed was Bagram prison in Afghanistan,” he had been subjected to the following abuse: “The interpreters who directed the questions to us did it with beatings and insults. They used cold water, ice water. They put us in a tub with cold water. We were forced [to go] for months without clothes. They brought a doctor at the beginning. He put my leg in a plaster. One of the methods of interrogation was to take the plaster off and stand on my leg.”

[T]he Post failed to follow up on the stories of the other prisoners mentioned in the Human Rights Watch press release, even though, in October 2007, Craig Whitlock had written a front-page article for the Post, “From CIA Jails, Inmates Fade Into Obscurity,” which included details of the four prisoners.

Just as the story of Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi should shine the most uncomfortable light on former Vice President Dick Cheney’s claims that the CIA’s web of secret prisons and proxy prisons protected America from further deadly attacks (and not, as it transpired, provided false information obtained through torture to justify an illegal war), so the stories of these four men deserve to be heard, to focus much-needed attention on a policy which, with no oversight from either Congress or the judiciary, allowed the Executive branch to indulge its dictatorial fantasies by “disappearing” prisoners anywhere around the world, and, in some cases, returning them to countries like Libya, with its notoriously poor human rights record, even when, as Craig Whitlock noted, at least two of these men “had nothing to do with al-Qaeda.”

Worthington, a journalist, blogger, historian, and the author of The Guantanamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison goes on to conclude by pointing out the hypocrisy with which the U.S., under the Bush Regime, decided to begin not only negotiating with, but actually working as partners with the terrorist regime in Libya…

And an even bigger story, to which I hope to return in future, involves asking searching questions of both the US and UK governments regarding their role in forcibly returning – or attempting to return – Libyan prisoners from Guantà¡namo, and Libyan residents in the UK, whose only crime, it appears, is to have been in the wrong place at the wrong time when Colonel Gaddafi, once regarded as a pariah and an international terrorist, became an ally in the “War on Terror,” and those who opposed him were transformed, overnight, from freedom fighters to terrorists.

Share article:

Reader Comments on

Following al-Libi’s ‘Suicide,’ What About the Other ‘Ghost Detainees’ in Libya, Elsewhere?

4 Comments

(Comments are now closed.)


4 Responses

  1. 1)
    hANOVER fIST said on 5/13/2009 @ 1:55pm PT: [Permalink]

    Thanks to the non-whore press, WE THE PEOPLE actually have some information as to the false information used to boondoggle the United States into an unnecessary, unjust and untrue war.

    This is why there should be NO BAILOUT for our Distraction Media.

  2. 2)
    Big Dan said on 5/14/2009 @ 7:29pm PT: [Permalink]

    Does anyone think he didn’t commit suicide? All this torture stuff is being talked about, then this guy crops up after all these years dead in a cell in Libya…right when everyone’s talking about the Bush administration’s torture! AGAIN…when you take each coincidence by itself, you can make excuses…when you put together ALL the “coincidences”, then there’s a pattern that they aren’t coincidences.

    – DC Madam commits suicide
    – Connell’s plane crashes
    – Wellstone’s plane crashes (the most vocal senator against the Iraq War wow! what a coincidence!)
    – 9/11 activist’s plane crashes
    – al Libi “commits suicide”
    – Ken Lay has a heart attack
    – that fannie mae/freddy mac guy “commits suicide”

    I can go on and on and on and on and on……….and so can YOU!!!!!!!! Didn’t Cheney have a secret hit team? Remember that story?

(Comments are now closed.)


Thanks to you, The BRAD BLOG has been trouble-making and muckraking for … 22 YEARS!!!

Please help The BRAD BLOG, BradCast and Green News Report remain independent and 100% reader and listener supported in our 23rd YEAR!!!

ONE TIME
any amount...

MONTHLY
any amount...

OR VIA SNAIL MAIL
Make check out to...
Brad Friedman / BRAD BLOG
7095 Hollywood Blvd., #594
Los Angeles, CA 90028

RECENT POSTS

The BRAD BLOG Reborn…

And it only took 20 years or so...

‘86 47’ or ‘Weekend at Donnie’s’: ‘BradCast’ 4/30/2026

Guests: Heather Digby Parton of Salon, 'Driftglass' of 'Pro Left Podcast' on the SCOTUS VRA ruling and fallout, the ballroom, Iran, Comey, Kimmel and much more!...

‘Green News Report’ – April 30, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

Corrupt SCOTUS Undermines U.S. Constitution, Guts Last Remaining Protections of Voting Rights Act: ‘BradCast’ 4/29/2026

Guest: Redistricting expert Dan Vicuña of Common Cause; Also: Comey's dumb new indictment; E. Jean Carroll wins again; More new lows for Trump approval...

Trump’s Activist Rightwing ‘Originalist’ Judges Strike Again in Texas: ‘BradCast’ 4/28/2026

Guest: Jay Willis of Balls and Strikes; Also: Dem takes polling lead for U.S. Senate in TX as Repubs brace for 'sour, ugly, bad, bleak' midterm elections...

‘Green News Report’ – April 28, 2026

With Brad Friedman and Desi Doyen

Trump, Repubs Exploit Failed Assassination Plot to Advance Ballroom Blitz: ‘BradCast’ 4/27/2026

What we know about the alleged shooter, Trump's opportunist response, corrupt contracting for the ballroom, fury at being described as a 'pedophile'; Also: Callers ring in!...

Sunday ‘So Much Winning’ Toons

THIS WEEK: Punch Drunk ... Kash Poor ... Forever War ... The Shadow Docket Knows! ...

So Much Losing: ‘BradCast’ 4/23/2026

In Iran, in public opinion, at the ballot box, in the courtroom...

‘Green News Report’ – April 23, 2026

With Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen...

‘A Scammer’s Treasure Trove’: DOGE Bros Stole Your Social Security Data: ‘BradCast’ 4/22/2026

Guest: Nancy Altman of Social Security Works; Also: 'Yes', Virginia, there is a new U.S. House map! (For now)...

Insiders Making a Killing Betting on Trump’s War: ‘BradCast’ 4/21/2026

Guest: Craig Holman of Public Citizen; Also: Judge blocks Admin scheme to prevent wind, solar development; Another TACO Tuesday for Iran...

‘Green News Report’ – April 21, 2026

With Brad Friedman & Desi Doyen...

Week 8: Iran War Lies Continue from Sundowning Gaslighter-in-Chief: ‘BradCast’ 4/20/2026

Also: Approval rating plummets; More Dem overperformance in NJ; VA voters voting; CA primary election chaos; Callers ring in...

Sunday ‘WWJD?’ Toons

THIS WEEK: Paging Dr. Jesus ... Strait Outta Hormuz ... It's What's for Dinner ...

About Brad Friedman...

Brad is an independent investigative journalist, blogger and broadcaster. Full Bio & Testimonials… Media Appearance Archive… Articles & Editorials Elsewhere… Contact…

He has contributed chapters to these books…
…And is featured in these documentary films…

BRAD BLOG ON THE AIR!

THE BRADCAST on KPFK/Pacifica Radio Network (90.7FM Los Angeles, 98.7FM Santa Barbara, 93.7FM N. San Diego and nationally on many other affiliate stations! ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneInApple Podcasts/iTunesiHeartAmazon Music

GREEN NEWS REPORT, nationally syndicated, with new episodes on Tuesday and Thursday. ALSO VIA PODCAST: RSS/XML feed | Pandora | TuneInApple Podcasts/iTunesiHeartAmazon Music

Media Appearance Archives…

AD
CONTENT

ADDITIONAL STUFF

Brad Friedman/
The BRAD BLOG Named...

Buzz Flash's 'Wings of Justice' Honoree
Project Censored 2010 Award Recipient
The 2008 Weblog Awards