Interesting cross examination of Rep. Patrick Toomey on today’s Hardball. Toomey is running in the Republican primary against Sen. Arlen Specter, who Toomey describes as a “Liberal” — just to give you an idea how far outta touch these Right Wingnutz are.
Anyway, Chris Matthews pressed him hard on his Anti-Abortion position, asking what he would do – after making abortions illegal in the US and in Pennsylvania as he supports – to enforce such a law.
Toomey started to discuss what would happen to the doctor, when Matthews cornered him to ask what would be done to the woman who – by Toomey’s own terms – would be a murderer in such a case. Toomey hemmed and hawed and had no answer, but refused to suggest jailtime or anything like it for the woman.
Well done, Chris. Don’t know why it all never occured to me in such stark terms before, but if the Anti-Abortionists believe that abortion is murder, one would assume they would back throwing a woman who “commits” one into jail. Or perhaps even sentencing them to the Death Penalty since it would be, by their own definition, a capital crime.
To date, I’ve yet to see a “pro-life” politician who called for anything but punishment of the doctor who performs the operation in such a supposed crime.
Is the Anti-Abortionists very own premise (“Abortion is murder”) simply that weak? Or are they just too cowardly to actually stand behind their own purported convictions?
(I now look forward to DittoHead replies speaking to the Liberal position against the Death Penalty in lieu of an actual explanation for the hypocrisy of the Conservative position on Abortion. When you can’t defend yourself, of course, attack the other guy. See any recent Bush attack ad on Kerry for further instructions.)
P.S. Catholic Priest and Novelist Andrew M. Greeley followed that segment on Hardball to toss in an interesting statistic. He once did a survey to find out who was both Anti-Abortion and Anti-War, both tenets of Catholic faith. The answer: just 6% of those surveyed were against both. Telling.
There are illegal things people do to their bodies (illegal drugs) so a woman who has an abortion should be subject to same illegalities.
Not sure I understand the thin thread (even for you) that you are drawing here.
But assuming you mean that Drug Abusers should be thrown into jail (I know Courtney Love is about to be tried for her illegal use of Oxycontin), then I guess you’d like to see Rush Limbaugh tried for same. And – returning to the actual topic of this entry – see a woman thrown in jail (or even give the Death Penalty) for the capital crime that would be abortion if you your Right Wing buddies had their way?
Do I understand you correctly?
Maybe since there are millions of women who have had abortions since Roe V. Wade, we should just have a Department of Abortion Prosecution. Courts designed solely for abortions, jails, gas chambers. Its a conservatives dream.
Yes – If abortion was illegal and a woman kills her baby, she should be tried for murder. She made her choice when she slept with the guy. I would make an exception for rape and incest, however, it has been proven that a woman’s chance of getting pregnant after a stressful event like those is close to 0%.