You’ve heard the stunning news from the GOP’s packed and stolen Supreme Court by now. But whatever you have heard, it’s likely even worse than that, as explained on today’s BradCast. [Audio link to full show follows below.]
For years in the U.S., polling has found that huge majorities of Americans oppose overturning Roe v. Wade, 1973’s landmark, 7 to 2 SCOTUS opinion (with five Republicans voting in its majority), establishing the now, long-settled Constitutional right to abortion services in all 50 states. Polling released today from just last week confirms Roe’s popularity, with approximately 2 to 1 majority support across the country.
On Monday night, however, Politico published an unprecedented leak of a 98-page draft opinion written by Justice Samuel Alito, on behalf of a reported 5 to 4 Court majority, that would completely overturn Roe and a number of other rulings that had further affirmed it more recent years.
Unless one of the Justices decides to change their vote between now and the final release of the opinion over the next two months, it will then be left to states to decide whether they wish to allow women the right to have the procedure. In nearly two dozen states, it will immediately become unlawful if the draft majority opinion is published. In Texas, for example, “The second Roe is struck down, it will be a first degree felony — punishable by life in prison — for a Texas doctor to perform an abortion for a woman who was raped and impregnated by a family member.”
As terrible as that is, it could get even worse. Earlier rulings that helped establish the right to reproductive freedom for women, and several that came after Roe, would then be teed up to be overturned as well by the radical Rightwing activists now packed onto our SCOTUS. Rights to purchase contraception and for same-sex marriage could also be overturned, just to name two such “unenumerated rights” that, like abortion, have been established by the Court even though they are not specifically named in the Constitution.
And for those who have been conned by the same liars who said claimed Roe would never be overturned, that the GOP didn’t really want that to happen, who are now being told that overturning Roe would simply leave it to states to decide whether or not women are allowed to enjoy personal liberty, there is already a national movement afoot to ban abortion at the federal level. If Roe is struck down, as now appears almost certain, all it will require is a GOP majority in each chamber of Congress and a Republican in the White House to turn the clock back 50 years in all 50 states.
Lots to discuss today, obviously, including the dishonest remarks Samuel Alito offered during his 2006 Senate confirmation hearings before he was granted his lifetime appointment, when he lied in his answer as to whether he believed Roe to be settled law. Also, regrets today — apparently, they have a few — from theoretically pro-choice Republican Senators Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska. Both previously said they were convinced by Trump’s anti-choice nominees to the High Court — Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett — that Roe would remain in place. So, they each supported Trump’s nominations, even after Mitch McConnell blew up the filibuster rule for lifetime appointments to the Supreme Court in order to pack them onto it. In Barrett’s case, she was seated just eight days before the 2020 Presidential election, after Republicans refused to even allow a vote on Barack Obama’s nominee for a year following the death of Antonin Scalia in 2016.
We’re joined today by attorney and former law school teacher turned journalist and podcaster, JESSICA MASON PIEKLO, Executive Editor of Rewire News Group. She last joined us on the program back when Kavanaugh was similarly lying his way through his own confirmation hearings.
She predicted in June of 2021 — when the Court first took up Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the case now being decided by the Court, the Mississippi case seeking to ban abortions after 15 weeks, in violation of Roe — that SCOTUS was preparing to overturn Roe entirely. “This is the Supreme Court Case That Will End ‘Roe v. Wade,'” she warned at the time. And that was well before Barrett was even nominated.
“There was no reason for the Supreme Court to take up the Dobbs case unless it had plans to overturn Roe v. Wade. That’s just a fundamental fact,” she explains today. “At the time, there was not a single federal court in the country that thought that law was Constitutional. Every court that looked at this issue, whether it was Mississippi’s law or copycat laws in other states across the country, had said the Constitution, Roe v. Wade, Planned Parenthood v. Casey, very clearly do not allow states the power to ban abortion before fetal viability. Then Amy Coney Barrett happened, and here we are.”
When Dobbs was taken up at SCOTUS last year, she explains, “the question was whether or not the Court was going to uphold the Mississippi law within the confines of Roe v. Wade. So, as of June last year, even the state of Mississippi hadn’t asked the Court to formally overturn Roe v. Wade.” But after Barrett was seated, just before the 2020 election, MS began asking the Court to fully overturn it. “It’s a full bait-and-switch,” charges Pieklo today.
Worse, she explains, Alito’s leaked draft opinion “doesn’t just call for overturning ‘Roe’. It really attacks privacy rights writ large, makes it clear that they’re coming for rights like marriage equality…sodomy bans…birth control. All of those things are there. Fetal personhood is there. There’s just so much to be concerned about [with] the plans that are there.”
Think none of that stuff could ever happen? Yeah, Collins and Murkowski probably agree with you.
What can be done? We discuss. But, as we’ve been explaining for some time, never mind Conventional Wisdom that says Democrats will take a shellacking this November. These are decidedly unconventional times. Stop whining. Get to work…
“Mississippi find yourself another country to be part of.”
– Phil Ochs