On today’s BradCast: Our last show before a long holiday weekend packs a wallop and finds not just the President of the United States in violation of the Constitution, but also Alabama’s Secretary of State. Also: zombies! [Audio link to show follows below.]
First up, President Trump found an excuse today to bail out of the planned June 12th nuclear summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong-Un, stunning allies in South Korea with a letter to Kim that sounded not unlike a bad breakup letter from a “needy” boyfriend, meant to keep his girlfriend from breaking up with him first — while begging her to come back. We share the bizarre letter in full, along with both reactions to it and reasons behind it.
Then, it’s been an interesting week for the First Amendment and those who claim to be “Constitutional conservatives”, as Scott Pruitt’s EPA locked out mainstream media outlets, such as AP and CNN, from a major water contamination forum, and as a federal judge in New York ruled that Trump was personally violating the Constitutional First Amendment free speech rights of seven plaintiffs who sued after he blocked them on Twitter. (My interview with one of the plaintiffs earlier this year, legal journalist Rebecca Showalter-Poza, is here.) The Dept. of Justice is said to be reviewing the court’s ruling and may appeal.
While those plaintiffs were purportedly blocked from seeing or responding to Trump’s Twitter feed, because he disagreed with their political points of view, the case echoes a similar matter that we discussed some months ago, after I was blocked on Twitter by Alabama Sec. of State John Merrill (R) in the midst of a bizarre conversation [PDF] in which I politely corrected the Secretary for erroneous public statements made about his state’s computerized vote tabulation systems.
We’re joined today to discuss both of those free speech matters and more by University of Kentucky College of Law professor JOSHUA A. DOUGLAS, who was also blocked by Merrill on Twitter last year after mentioning to him that “blocking people on Twitter, blocking his own constituents on Twitter, could violate the First Amendment”.
Douglas, whose assertion was bared out by the federal judge in New York this week, explains the ruling and what may happen next in the case (will Trump end up pushing the case and violating a federal court order and then attempt to pardon himself as a test run for the future?), and I share an emailed response to my query from Merrill this morning in full, as the blocks continue on Twitter in apparent violation of the Constitution.
The central part of Merrill’s response to me today [emphasis added]:
While I don’t think Merrill actually owns Twitter quite as much as he seems to think he does, there was actually no political view or agenda expressed in my conversation with him that resulted in the block. More importantly, as Douglas notes in response to Merrill’s remarks today: “Once someone like Donald Trump or John Merrill begins to use his Twitter account in a governmental capacity, then he can’t pick and choose and block someone because he thinks, in his own view, that that person is promoting some sort of political agenda. That’s really what the core of the First Amendment is all about, and that’s what this court said.”
Douglas, a Constitutional law and elections expert in Kentucky, also offers his thoughts on this week’s upset victory by political newcomer Amy McGrath over DCCC-recruited Lexington Mayor Jim Gray in the primary contest for the Democratic nomination to challenge Rep. Andy Barr (R) this November in Douglas’ own district. His take, particularly on the “conservative” bent of the two Democratic candidates, is somewhat different than the one offered by BlueAmericaPAC’s Howie Klein on yesterday’s program.
Then, we’re joined by Desi Doyen for an incredibly news-chocked and, at times, quite troubling Green News Report. And, finally, to lighten things up just a bit before a long holiday weekend, an actual story about a “ZOMBIE ALERT!” issued in south Florida this past week. No, really!…
So much for the rule of law.
Trump Ignores Court Ruling That He Can’t Block Twitter Critics: ‘President Thinks He’s Above the Law’